Coffaro's Pizza is a pizzeria South River located in United States.
58 Obert St South River , NJ 08882 United States
LOL. We've been open since 1948 and cash only for all of those 65yrs. The pizza slices ready are indeed all plain...all other pizza is made FRESH to order.
I deliver for another pizza place and on my break I go to coffaros for a special.
There's a reason why this place has been open 65 years. It's one reason my extended family (who used to live in SR) still come back into town . Grab the special. 2 slices and a coke for $5.
All the lights were off - had no pizzas out because they only make plain. Asked what the minimum was for debit and they don't accept cards - how is this place even open???
Delicious. That authentic submarine sandwich taste. - Dwayne Dority
Slowest place ever!! - Lauren ❄ Voicheck
Coffee is awesome. Sandwiches are amazing. Staff is so friendly unlike those asshats at Speedway. - Jenn Urquhart