Nightingale Supper Club

Nightingale Supper Club is a american restaurant Sturgeon Bay located in United States.

adsense
8 / 10
58
ratings
  • Phone

    (920) 743-5593

  • Website

    nightingalesupperclub.com

  • Facebook

    130411703646762

  • Type

    American Restaurant

Address

1541 Egg Harbor Rd (Alabama St.) Sturgeon Bay , WI 54235 United States

Reservations Yes
Credit Cards Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi Free
Outdoor Seating No
Music Live Music
Menus Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
Adsense

Comments / 20


Keywords:

prime rib grasshopper garlic mashed potatoes surf & turf good for dates loaded potatoes asparagus soup takes reservations cocktails dinner good for special occasions parking
Jim Bailey

Yup the prime rib was amazing. Great local Super Club, a must try.

Dave & Barbara Reinbold

Mondays is lobster night and 8 ounces of superb tail is delicious! Asparagus with crab soup is over the top excellent, surf and turf great choice, cocktails perfect????We’ll be back!

Kyle Kubichek

Absolutely amazing! Call ahead to make a reservation because they are busy but worth the wait! Tenderloin and shrimp combo with garlic mashed .... out of this world!

Luke C

A local favorite. Monday night is lobster night and it's outstanding.

Tammy Raymond

Did is very good, service is great, and cocktails are the bomb.

Cathie Marty

Excellent food & service - reservations suggested!

Rebecca Battista-Sullivan

Absolutely amazing asparagus and lobster soup !! Yummmm!

Nathan Nowack

Best prime rib around!! Also get a frozen alcoholic grasshopper !!

Mike Blackley

This is my favorite local place for Prime Rib !

Dan Reynard

Awsome prime rib , wish I got up here a little more often.

James

Prime rib is awesome!!

Patrick Normoyle

Told wait was an hour ended up being two. Couldn't order appetizers while waiting. Food expensive . Service was slow. Tenderloin Oscar was saltly in sauce. Crab she'll pieces in crab meat . Not good.

Jeremy Evensen

Prime rib !

Alison Walker

Prime Rib sandwich ...amazing!!!

Jackie Pavlat Snow

Amazing!!!!!

Nathan Nowack

Best prime

Larry Kedzie

Great prime rib

Patrick Normoyle

Told wait was an hour..ended up being two. Couldn't order appetizers while waiting for table. Service slow. Tenderloin Oscar sauce was too salty. Food was too expensive

Jamie Schilling

One of the worst experiences I have ever had. Especially at a supper club.

Manda Soyk

BAD service. Lengthy. Sent a steak back TWICE; still not good.

Adsense

Similar places nearby :

6.9
American
Wanda Jean's Family Restaurant

The blueberry pancakes are ok. Service is friendly! Large cups of coffee - Lori Borgmann

9.0
American
Inn at Cedar Crossing

Cherry pie, hummus, falafel bites & chili. Burgers are excellent. - Kouros Mohit

American
Betsy Ross Family Restaurant

Service is excellent. Nice family restaurant. - Sally Huggins

5.9
Big Box Store
Walmart Supercenter

Oh my gosh, the bathrooms are amazing! Big stalls for all! - Jennifer Brefczynski

7.5
Resort
Stone Harbor Resort & Conference Center

Stone Harbor Resort is fabulous. Room amenities are over the top. Dinner at the Pub was amazing! Had prime rib and blackened grouper. Pic is of the grouper. - Karen Heffernan Gunaka