Our sandwiches are the best in the whole valley, or maybe in the whole country, you be the judge!
160 W 2nd S Rexburg , ID 83440 United States
| Credit Cards | Yes |
| Outdoor Seating | No |
Everything. Especially when you add Gator Ranch to your fries and sandwich
Try the jack, it's stacked with meat and cheese .
Although the name is scary the sandwich "De Mudder in Law " (turkey , bacon , avocado ) is really good!
I love their teriyaki bowls .
You can't go wrong with the De Mudder In Law !
Gator Bites are good. Sandwiches are unimpressive. Just another addition to the lonnnnng list of mediocre sandwich places in Rexburg.
Makin a squeal bbq pork is bomb . Come for breakfast too
If you haven't tried their breakfast burritos you are missin out.
Makin a squeal and de mudder in law are amazing
Note: Don't touch the gators on the counter. Babies suck on them.
I love the rum runner .
Da Mudder In Law is so delicious!
Not fresh and overcrowded.
I got a horrible stomach ache after eating here. Super greasy and expensive . I'd rather go to Great Harvest...
Spicy Italian is basically the Italian BMT without one slice of meat. And usually cheaper! Have them toast it with the salami on top for a crispier tastier sandwich. - Aaron Ellis
The Southern Style Chicken Sandwich has surprisingly soft buns. Delicious. - Braden M
Great selection especially in the toppings! Caramel Apple is super delicious! - Jonnie Blake
The benches on the main level are very soft and a great place for passing time! - Ashlynn Green